Articles

Articles

Your Employer Says You’re Qualified. IRCC Says You’re Not. Who Is Right?

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Authored by Renz Grospe, Canadian Immigration Lawyer, RCG Legal Professional Corporation.  

Can IRCC refuse your work permit even if you have an approved LMIA, years of experience, and an employer willing to hire you? 

Five Federal Court decisions reveal an interesting answer: Yes, but immigration officers cannot simply invent additional job requirements. 

When IRCC Gets It Wrong 

In Guitang v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 835 (CanLII), a Filipino caregiver was refused a work permit because she lacked certain training qualifications. However, these qualifications were not mandatory under the National Occupational Classification (NOC) and were not required by her employer’s Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA). 

The Federal Court overturned the refusal. 

Similarly, in Taheri v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 520 (CanLII), IRCC refused a flooring installer’s work permit because he did not submit a formal language assessment. 

The Court found the refusal unreasonable. The officer had imposed a language testing requirement that did not apply and failed to properly consider the applicant’s other evidence. 

The message? IRCC cannot automatically turn optional qualifications into mandatory requirements. 

But Having Experience Is Not Always Enough 

Now consider three other decisions. 

In Loyeung v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1360 (CanLII), an applicant had more than 10 years of experience as a cook. His work permit was nevertheless refused because he failed to provide proof of secondary school education, an express requirement in his LMIA. 

The Federal Court upheld the refusal. 

In Verma v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 798 (CanLII), an applicant had already worked for the same employer as an assistant manager. However, he failed to establish the required education or several years of relevant experience for a food service supervisor position. His judicial review was dismissed. 

Most recently, in Hussain v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1422 (CanLII), released on November 18, 2026, an applicant with approximately 19 years of work experience was refused because he failed to sufficiently demonstrate the English proficiency needed for his proposed job. 

The Federal Court upheld that refusal too. 

So, What’s the Difference? 

The distinction is not simply whether an applicant has experience or an approved LMIA. 

It is whether the officer imposed an unwarranted requirement or reasonably concluded that the applicant failed to establish an applicable qualification. 

An officer cannot automatically demand a certificate, diploma, or language test that is not required. 

But applicants must still provide convincing evidence that they can perform the proposed work. 

A positive LMIA does not guarantee work permit approval. 

What If Your Work Permit Was Refused? 

Before challenging a refusal, examine three things: 

  • The NOC: Does it say required, usually required, or may be required? 
  • The LMIA: What qualifications does the employer actually require? 
  • The evidence: Did the applicant properly demonstrate those qualifications? 

These distinctions can determine whether a judicial review has merit or whether a stronger new application is the better option. 

A refusal is not necessarily the end of the road. But understanding why IRCC refused your application is the first step toward choosing the right legal remedy. 

This article provides general legal information, not legal advice. 

Case Citations 

All decisions retrieved from CanLII on November 19, 2026. 

 

Become a member now!

Join a growing community of Canadian immigration lawyers, academics and law students.

Our Latest Articles